Film FreeQ: DC's Film Franchise a Lukewarm Start--But Hope for the Future?

The "DC Extended Universe" (DCEU) has gotten off to a surprisingly rocky start, perhaps as much as the anticipation that preceded it. What with the releases of this year's Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and Suicide Squad, the rival studio to Marvel has showcased some of the latest examples of blockbusters that represent a gap between critical and audience reception (or in some cases, a comparison of both). In fact, both films hold a 20 percent vicinity score on Rotten Tomatoes.

What is the reason then? Could these films really be poor in quality? Did critics and/or audiences each respectfully fail to understand the filmmakers' visions? Were the filmmakers too ambitious or too ahead of their time? Were they breaking new ground with stories that have relevance in today's culture? Did the studios reportedly interfere and demand cuts for these films (leading to extended director's cuts on home video later)? Is it just art and action for their own sake, or is there actually substance behind it or added to it? Or maybe it's all of these things, one way or another.

There certainly has been a long history of films that have met with lukewarm or poor reception upon their initial release, only to be met in later years with universal acclaim. Such examples include Citizen Kane, Fantasia, and 2001: A Space Odyssey. (WatchMojo.com has an interesting YouTube video on the subject.) Now, I'm not saying that history may eventually warm up to the ultimate duel between DC's most iconic heroes and their well-known rogue's gallery. For now, though, it's easy to see why audiences and critics continue to be divisive on these films.

Dawn of the Justice League in Batman v Superman

In retrospect, the "Extended Universe" for DC films began in 2013, one year after director Christopher Nolan concluded his highly-regarded Batman trilogy with The Dark Knight Rises. Director Zack Snyder's Man of Steel rebooted Superman's origin story in the same way Nolan and company did, by grounding the titular character in reality and setting him in a grittier world. What was different about Snyder's (and co-writer David S. Goyer's) take, while engrossing and well-meaning, was how grim and destructive it got, especially during the film's climax.

Snyder returned to the director's chair with the follow-up, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Set two years after the climactic events of the previous film, Superman is viewed as a threat and alternatively as a hero by the world. Bruce Wayne a.k.a. the Caped Crusader (Ben Affleck, in surprisingly fine form) views him as the former, and a clash of worldviews ensues in one of the year's most debatable and provocative films. Snyder's DC films (as well as the 2009 big-screen adaptation of the graphic novel Watchmen) have been criticized for being too dark and serious, much like Tim Burton's Batman movies from 1989 and 1992. According to Rotten Tomatoes, the film "smothers a potentially powerful story - and some of America's most iconic superheroes - in a grim whirlwind of effects-driven action."

To be sure, there certainly is a lot of action, CGI destruction, and much incoherence in the film's plot and execution -- at least according to views of the theatrical release. (An "ultimate edition" just released on video this past summer was praised even more than the initial release, with one reviewer on Amazon.com commending said version for filling significant plotholes and even discussing the film's philosophical and ethical undertones in meticulous detail.) Alongside Affleck, viewers got to see the scene-stealing feature debut of Diana Prince a.k.a. Wonder Woman (Fast & Furious's Gal Gadot), as well as fleeting cameos from future DC heroes.

Suicide Squad's rogues gallery

Suicide Squad is essentially an ensemble of DC supervillains, including the Joker, Harley Quinn, Deadshot, and Killer Croc. Having seen the theatrical cut, what starts out intriguing (with snippets of key characters and dark humor, not to mention an engaging soundtrack) becomes incoherent, lacking in character (much of Jared Leto's scenes as the Joker were left on the cutting room floor), and disappointingly conventional of superhero movies (i.e., a "save the world from total destruction" scenario). According to the consensus on Rotten Tomatoes, the film "boasts a talented cast and a little more humor than previous DCEU efforts, but they aren't enough to save the disappointing end result from a muddled plot, thinly written characters, and choppy directing."

On August 11 last month, an alleged former employee of Warner Bros. reportedly wrote an open letter to the respective studio executives, criticizing the studio's slate of theatrical releases since 2013, including DC's films. Despite these criticisms, the latter movies have made a lot of money at the box-office, and stand as two of the top ten highest-grossing films of 2016 worldwide. In addition, the folks at Warner Bros. and DC have taken steps to ensure that they're get back on the right track with their slate of future releases (read here), which will continue next year with the highly anticipated solo outing Wonder Woman and the equally anticipated ensemble Justice League.